Hi there. My little problem is that i can't choose between buying Max/MSP or diving for free in Pd. So i started to look for comparisons between these two.
As i see in wikipedia Max link http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_(software) there is a long list of well known artists (like Aphex Twin, Tim Hecker) who are using it. As for Pd, there is absolutely no information on the web about famous musicians who are working with this software..
So my question is do you know any electronic/electroacoustic artists who are using Pd?
Or maybe in generally Pd is well less professional than Max?
From what i have tried i can say that sound quality is identical, just Max's interface is far more advanced..
Maybe Pd better suited for game music and for creating things like Reactable?
Thanks for answers.
-
Artists using Pure Data
-
Hey,
I'm quite missing some tool for fast patch debugging in pd. In MAX if you hover over the cable passing data are shown in floating box. In pd you have to connect number box to know... might be time consuming when tracking some data ( btw. also sending bang via mouse (right click context menu when hovering over the inlet?) would be helpful...)
ales -
i prefer pd than max.
i dont like max 5 gui , is is not simple and direct.
and i have the same feeling that pd is more stable than max.
but the usability design of max is better than pd.
and max 5 help center is better too.vea
-
I have been attempting to create some music with Pd for about two weeks. It is difficult to understand the theory of the program and to solve issues (errors, patches that are downloaded and don't work as they should etc.). Although I appreciate the flexibility, there is what I would term a "steep learning curve" here. I'm not sure how long I can pursue before I have to find an easier way to get to the things I want to do. Ultimately I am in it for the music and the programming part is a tool. I wish there was clearer documentation so that I could get simple answers. Your thoughts would be appreciated.
-
It's true that there's quite some learning curve with pd. I've needed 2 attempts to get into it. The first attempt I was rather impatient and was overwelmed by all possibilities and got nowhere. The second time i've given myself about a month time of really trying. What I've noticed is that it helps if you know exactly what you want to achieve. Sometimes it can be better to limit yourself to try to implement just 1 simple idea, instead of trying to get to grips with everything at the same time. So if you have something in your mind and you really don't know where to get started, just post it here and people will try to help you out.
|] [] |.| ][|-| -- http://soundcloud.com/domxh
-
@domien said:
What I've noticed is that it helps if you know exactly what you want to achieve.
This is great advice.
I found that the best way to learn Pd is to start with a clear, simple goal in mind. If possible, break this goal down further into its components and work on one component at a time until you have achieved your goal.
Repeat.
-
The FLOSS manual is a great place to get started. I didn't discover it until about a year after I started using Pd, but I wish I'd found it sooner. It definitely would've saved me some time.
-
Thank you pd123 and domien these are encouraging words and may be just what I need to get things to happen. I'll give your advice a try iso don't be surprised if you see some specific questions come your way.
multijd -
Hi, now i have one little problem on win 7: i can't open any patch via help browser, it stopped working. When i click any of control or audio examples, or any other - nothing happens. Is there any way to sort this problem? Tried reinstall, but didn't helped.
-
In my experience, I couldn't even use max because it was a lagging crash fiesta. Get Pd because it is awesome.
-
Here is my experience...
im learning pd before i buy max/msp , since pd is a lot like max but free and there is a whole lot more documentation on PD than max, and the people who developed PD are the same people developing MAX (from what ive read) i figured id learn PD before buying MAX.
This has a lot to do with me buying Reaktor 5 before i learned programming and hated myself for years for that and ended up using the library and almost never opened reaktor after that.
After about 3 or 4 months of annoying reading on PD im on my way to building my first FM synthesis drum machine so yay! i dont feel so stupid now and studying on PD is making me understand Reaktor 5 so im guessing itll help me with max/msp as well.
so take it from someone who made an idiotic choice on purchasing software about 2 years ago based on who is using it, being a fan of richard devine and datachi and electroacoustic music.
Software wont make you sound great only studying hard will.
PD is a great place to start and im guessing itll be a great place to stay...hope this helps.
-
I'm not famous but my new CD will contain many uses of Pd
also check out the article I wrote on my switch from OS X -> Linux
-
i was thinking about purchasing a new mac and the prices made me think twice but the article is making me think thrice.
From what i read on the comments Linux handles supercollider, pd and reaktor! im definetly considering Linux but im not strong in the programming department i wouldnt want to get tangled in the programming to make it stable and then start producing sounds... i need to read more about Linux before i say anything or make a desition.thanks
-
@Roaramburu: you will probably do more fixing the tweaking in Windows than Linux...you can also try Linux from a DVD or usb stick before installing it
-
@anechoic said:
I'm not famous but my new CD will contain many uses of Pd
also check out the article I wrote on my switch from OS X -> Linux
Great! I have Linux/Windos/OSX installed. I discover GNU/Linux 8 years ago. If your favorite software is on Linux, use linux!
Kim, the other day I discover your work, searching for MAX/MSP music. Great to see you here. Im new to MAX/PD, as a MAX user, what do you think of PD? -
I stopped using Max/MSP at version 4.6.x so I never made the switch to Max5 although I have been using M5 to port a vintage studio app to Pd. There are things I really like about Pd but it did take a little while to warm up to the UI and certain quirks. Other than that I'm very happy with it and have been using it everyday for the past 6 months or so for various projects I've been working on.
-
@anechoic said:
I stopped using Max/MSP at version 4.6.x so I never made the switch to Max5 although I have been using M5 to port a vintage studio app to Pd.
Was this patch written in Max 4.6 or 5? It used to be that before Max5 you could just change the extension of Max patches to .pd and open them in Pd. The file format was ridiculously similar. And the cyclone/maxmode stuff made it even more compatible. You'd still probably have to do some editing, but it would still be less work than repatching everything by hand. Max5's file format is much different, though.
-
PdX can open max patches but it tends to mangle subpatches depending on the complexity of the Max patch -- I tried opening the vintage studio patch and it was a mess
-
How to connect gemmouse with hslider? I want when I move the mouse, to move sound too.
-
I know this is an old post, but I would like to say something, please.
I'm non native english, you know what I mean...
Well, electronic music is my life. I'll never be famous for make money doing it, but I already knew that from the beginning. I just work on another jobs to eat, such is life.
But I insist, is not a hobby for me, it's my lifestyle.
My advice:
Think about what really you want and how much are you willing to risk.
When I think on my gnu/linux computer with pd I can only smile and appreciate their absolute freedom, and always music and freedom go hand in hand. But remember, freedom was never the easy way. Think about that.
I hope I have helped you snowball and not being too pedantic.
