Hello

I try to use [pgmin] and it appears to only output "1" when I send PROGRAM CHANGES
the program changes I checked with midiox appear to be correct (see picture below)

[ctlin] works fine, so I guess there is bug with [pgmin]

any advice would be appreciated

sheers

@phil123456 How are you using it? With an argument?
Are you looking at the left outlet?
If you use [pgmin 1] do you get the correct data?
If you attach a [print] are you actually getting the correct data followed immediately by "1"......?

I have never seen a complaint before so?
David.

I tried with 2 outlets, and with 1 outlet, giving it the channel as argument, althought it seems to react, it only outputs 1, no other value

but since I made the controller myself with an arduino , could be that I send the wrong data, but they look ok in midiosx

@phil123456 Yes, it looks correct in midiOx.
Does a [print] tell you more?

wtf??? it actualy prints 2 numbers ... how do I recuperate the first actual value ?

print: 127 <<<<<<< how d I get this one ?
print: 1
print: 126
print: 1

Ok I figured this one , but I still dont understand why I have to do all that while the example seemed much simpler

@phil123456 It must be something in the incoming midi.
You can filter the "1" easily with a [route 1]
But you will need to catch......
1
1
as a real "1" as well maybe?
This will do it for your incoming data.......... with_1.pd ....
although there must surely be an easier way.
David.