Hi, I am starting on the examples in Andy Farnell's "Designing Sound" but I am also trying to translate the patches into Max as I go. I am wondering if anyone on this list might know which Max objects will work best to replace [bp~] and [hip~]. I am currently replacing [bp~] with [reson~] and I'm replacing [hip~] with the right outlet of [cross~]. However, I am getting slightly different results than Farnell's examples. At the moment I'm dealing specifically with the "phonetones" examples and even more specifically with the contents of the "tline" subpatcher.

Hoping someone can offer a little advice. Thanks.

Sorry, somehow I didn't make the second post I intended. I've attached the Max 5 patch to compare to the Pd patch in my previous post.

http://www.pdpatchrepo.info/hurleur/filter_test.maxpat

Thanks for the replies. I ended up discovering that the discrepancy in sound was really originating with [bp~] and [reson~]. These two filters just don't sound the same and I've tried different Q settings between the two and just can't get them to sound the same.

If anyone around here uses Pd and Max 5 (and cares) I've attached two patches that show the difference in sound between the two.

http://www.pdpatchrepo.info/hurleur/filter_test.pd