Producing two note offs here instead of a note on and a note off?

Any ideas why?

R

Works fine here. 0.42.5-extended on OSX 10.5.

It reads fine in the console window, but using MIDI monitor it reads as two note off messages, which ain't good when trying to use it with other software. The work around is to create a note on and note off manually using messages straight into [noteout].

can you make a quick patch to demonstrate? that's pretty weird

The patch is no different from the [makenote] helpfile. I'm using MIDI monitor to monitor the MIDI note state. Let me know if you get two note offs.

http://www.snoize.com/MIDIMonitor/

ok, so i downloaded MIDI monitor, and got it going fine.

[makenote] has 2 outlets.

[noteout] has 3 inlets.

if i connect it correctly, ie the left outlet of [makenote] to the left inlet of [makenote] and then the right outlet of [makenote] to the middle inlet of [noteout], it works fine as it should.

i can force two noteoffs by connecting it the wrong way. if i connect the right outlet of [makenote] to the 3rd inlet of the [noteout] it gives me 2 note off's. is that what you're doing?

Yes, you're right. It might be worth while demonstrating the correct configuration in the [makenote]/[noteout] help file as I don't think it is implicit (although when you point it out, it makes perfect sense).

Thanks mod.